David Brennan Surpasses 1,000 Points in Breakout Junior Campaign for Old Tappan Golden Knights

Photo Credits: High School Sports Elite

After scoring 455 points through 26 games, David Brennan of Old Tappan High School, added points in the final game of the season, pushing his career mark past 1,000 points. He now stands among the top scorers in program history with another full season still ahead.

He averaged 18.3 points per game across 27 contests and delivered steady production all winter. David Brennan reached double figures in 25 of 27 games and scored 20 or more seven times.

His biggest performance came in a 68 to 65 road win at Demarest, where he poured in 35 points. He added 25 at Bergenfield, 24 at Dwight Englewood, and two separate 23 point efforts against Randolph and Pascack Valley. When Old Tappan needed offense, Brennan responded.

He scored efficiently from every level.
136 made two point field goals.
32 three pointers.
85 of 96 from the free throw line, good for 88.5 percent. One of the highest free throw percentages in the state.

Late in games, that free throw percentage gave the Golden Knights control.

The Old Tappan Boys Basketball did not officially post rebounds this season, but David Brennan consistently battled on the glass on both ends. Based on his presence and activity level, he likely would have led or finished near the top of the team in rebounding as well.

Beyond scoring and rebounds, Brennan’s all around production placed him among the most complete players in the state. His per game averages in scoring, assists, and rebounds rank inside the top 100 in New Jersey in all three categories. Few players impact the game across every column the way he does. He creates offense for teammates, finishes possessions on the glass, and carries the scoring load.

His growth shows in the numbers.

Freshman year: 245 points.
Sophomore year: 283 points.
Junior year: 475 points.

He has nearly doubled his freshman output and now enters his senior year with over 1,000 career points and rising expectations. Brennan’s next step is clear. Lead deeper into the postseason and elevate the standard even higher.

Now, his focus shifts from the hardwood to the diamond.

David Brennan is also a high level pitcher for Old Tappan Golden Knights and will take the mound this spring. His competitive edge, control under pressure, and ability to command late game moments in basketball translate directly to baseball. He attacks hitters the same way he attacks defenses.

With over 1,000 career points secured and baseball season next, Brennan from Old Tappan High School, continues to prove he is one of the premier multi sport athletes in the state.

Source Link: https://highschoolsports.nj.com/player/david-brennan-2/boysbasketball/season/2025-2026

Athlete's Latest Article

Old Tappan has a real shot to win the state section championship

Feb 22, 2026

Sixth-seeded Old Tappan enters North 1, Group 3 with more than hope. The Knights have proof. They are 18 to 6. They were ranked inside the Top 20 earlier this season. They beat strong programs like New Providence, River Dell, Pascack Valley, Paterson Eastside, Ridgewood, and Hasbrouck Heights. Those wins show they handle pressure and different styles. The losses matter more. Old Tappan fell by slim margins to Demarest, Teaneck, West Orange, and Ramapo. They pushed Demarest to overtime in one meeting and lost the other by three. That gap is one or two possessions. In a sectional setting, that is nothing. They also enter the tournament on a four game win streak. Teams that peak late are dangerous. The formulaIf the Knights: Keep turnovers under 10 Win the rebounding margin Close quarters strong they can beat anyone in this bracket. Higher seeds may have the home floor. Old Tappan has experience, momentum, and two proven scorers. That is enough to pull off a sectional run.

Senior Night Moment Lifts Old Tappan in 59 to 44 Win Over River Dell

Feb 19, 2026

Senior Night carried extra weight inside the gym as the Old Tappan Golden Knights honored Mia Derrico, Nina Caunedo, Sienna Drullinsky, and Sadie Murphy before their 59 to 44 win over the River Dell Golden Hawks. The most powerful moment came seconds after tipoff. Mia Derrico was sidelined for the season with a knee injury. She had not played a game all season. On Senior Night, she returned to the starting lineup. The opening tip was directed to her. She caught the ball, drove straight to the basket, and finished with a layup. Those two points were her first and only basket of the season. The crowd erupted. Teammates swarmed her. The moment set the tone for the night. From there, Old Tappan handled business. The first quarter ended tied at 16. The Knights led 25 to 24 at halftime. They created separation in the third quarter, outscoring River Dell 16 to 9. An 18 point fourth quarter closed the door. Drullinsky led all scorers with 30 points, dominating with her jump shot and converting six free throws. Nina Caunedo added 10 points with two three pointers. Sadie Murphy knocked down two shots from beyond the arc for six points. Alexa Caunedo scored eight. Alivia Badurina added a three. Mauimi Quiros, Madison Plescia, Farrah Ibrahim, Katie Degennaro, and Joley Giordano all saw action and contributed with defense, movement, and energy that helped control the pace. Old Tappan improved to 17 and 6. Senior Night delivered emotion, resilience, and a moment Mia Derrico will carry long after the final buzzer.

Old Tappan Erupts in Second Quarter, Tops Pascack Valley 52 to 36

Feb 17, 2026

Old Tappan erased a slow start and rolled past Pascack Valley, 52 to 36, on Tuesday afternoon. Pascack Valley jumped out to a 15 to 5 lead after one quarter. Old Tappan answered with a dominant second quarter, outscoring Pascack Valley 20 to 4. That stretch flipped the game. Old Tappan took a 25 to 19 lead into halftime and controlled the pace the rest of the way. Sienna Drullinsky led the charge with 26 points. She scored 11 field goals and added four free throws. She established position early, finished through traffic, and set the tone inside. Alexa Caunedo added 12 points on six two point baskets. She attacked the lane and converted efficiently. Sadie Murphy finished with nine points, knocking down a three and scoring twice inside. Alivia Badurina hit a three pointer for three points. Christina D'Andrea added two points in the win. Mauimi Quiros contributed at the line, converting two free throws. Nina Caunedo logged minutes and helped apply defensive pressure. Farrah Ibrahim provided energy off the bench. Katie Degennaro added depth in the rotation. Joley Giordano saw plenty of time and supported the defensive effort and brought in key rebounds on both sides of the court. Old Tappan finished with 21 two point field goals, two three pointers, and six made free throws. The defense limited Pascack Valley to eight two point field goals and three from beyond the arc. After a tough first quarter, Old Tappan responded with composure and execution. The second quarter surge created separation. The team closed strong and secured its 16th win of the season.