Dec 30, 2025
Game 1 recap. Jack Reilly Tournament. First round.Old Tappan opened the tournament with a 53 to 44 win over Passaic at Fort Lee.The game stayed tight early. Old Tappan led 9 to 7 after the first quarter. The offense settled in during the second quarter. Old Tappan outscored Passaic 16 to 7 and took a 25 to 14 lead into halftime.Passaic responded in the third quarter with 19 points. Old Tappan matched the push with 17 points and protected the lead. Both teams scored 11 in the fourth quarter, which closed out the win.David Brennan led Old Tappan with 14 points. He scored from multiple spots and paced the offense. Carmine Porcelli added 11 points and finished a perfect 6 for 6 at the free throw line. Isaac Shrager also scored 11 points, including a three. Luke Behrens contributed 9 points and provided steady scoring inside. Joseph Martin added 6 points. Oliver Vorros scored 2 points at the line. Brian Slater played and brought defensive pressure.Old Tappan finished with balanced scoring and strong second quarter execution. The win moved Old Tappan into the next round of the Jack Reilly Tournament.Game 2 recap. Jack Reilly Tournament.Old Tappan advanced with a 61 to 54 win over North Bergen at Fort Lee.Old Tappan set the tone early and led 12 to 9 after the first quarter. The second quarter created separation. Old Tappan scored 17 points and held North Bergen to 6, taking a 29 to 15 halftime lead.North Bergen closed the gap in the second half. Old Tappan stayed composed and answered each run. The fourth quarter turned into a scoring battle. Old Tappan scored 21 points in the final period to secure the win.David Brennan led all scorers with 17 points and controlled the pace. Carmine Porcelli followed with 16 points, including two threes. Isaac Shrager added 8 points with a three and free throws. Joseph Martin scored 9 points and finished through contact. Luke Behrens added 9 points and knocked down a three. Brian Slater chipped in 2 points at the line. Jake Totten played key minutes.Old Tappan shot well from the line and finished with balanced scoring across the rotation. The win pushed Old Tappan into the championship game.Game 3. Jack Reilly Tournament. Championship. December 30thOld Tappan won the title with a 46 to 41 victory over Randolph at Fort Lee High School.The game stayed close throughout. Old Tappan led 10 to 8 after the first quarter. Randolph tied the game at halftime, 15 to 15.Old Tappan took control in the third quarter with a 16 to 14 edge. The defense held firm in the fourth quarter and closed the game at the line.David Brennan delivered a standout performance with 23 points. He scored from the floor and went 7 for 8 at the line. Carmine Porcelli scored 8 points. Isaac Shrager added 8 points with timely free throws. Luke Behrens hit a three. Joseph Martin scored 4 points. Brian Slater anchored the defense. Old Tappan limited clean looks late and finished strong.Tournament summary.Old Tappan went 3 and 0 at the Jack Reilly Tournament and won the championship by beating Passaic, North Bergen, and Randolph.The team showed balance in the opening rounds and toughness in the title game. Old Tappan outscored opponents in second and fourth quarters across the tournament. Free throw shooting and defensive discipline decided close moments.David Brennan led the tournament run with scoring consistency, including a 23 point effort in the final. Carmine Porcelli, Isaac Shrager, Luke Behrens, and Joseph Martin provided steady secondary scoring. Brian Slater set the tone defensively throughout the tournament.Old Tappan finished the weekend with three wins, strong execution, and a tournament title.
